Is Someone Reading Over Your Shoulder?
Campaign For Reader Privacy
Campaign for Reader Privacy News
printer friendly version
For information contact:
Oren Teicher (ABA), 800-637-0037, ext. 6611
Larry Siems (PEN), 212-334-1660 ext. 105
Judith Platt (AAP), 202-220-4551
Bernadette Murphy (ALA), 202-628-8410 ext. 236

The book groups welcomed passage of S. 1389, a bill they say is much stronger than the House version, H.R. 3199, which passed on July 21. The House legislation, which like the Senate bill re-authorizes expiring sections of the PATRIOT Act, allows the FBI to search the bookstore and library records of anyone, including people who are not suspected of a crime, whenever they are "relevant" to a counter-terrorism or counter-espionage investigation. The Senate bill limits searches to the records that pertain to people who are suspected terrorists or spies and people who are in contact with them, reducing the danger that that the FBI will engage in fishing expeditions in bookstore and library records.

The Senate bill extends the section affecting bookstore and library records, Section 215, for only four years, while the House bill extends it 10 years. A shorter sunset ensures more oversight by Congress.

S. 1389 further strengthens key reader protections by allowing a bookseller, librarian, or anyone else who receives a search order under Section 215 to consult an attorney and to challenge the order in court. It requires an FBI agent to obtain written approval from the FBI Director or Deputy Director before applying for a Section 215 order for bookstore or library records. The legislation requires records sought to be described with “sufficient particularity” to allow them to be identified. The Justice Department would also have to report annually the number of bookstore and library searches it has conducted under Section 215.

“We are pleased that the Senate has unanimously consented to restore so many key reader privacy protections,” said Michael Gorman, President of the American Library Association. “We hope that the restorations of civil liberties made by the Senate will be preserved in the Conference Committee.”

“The Senate has taken a significant step toward satisfying our concerns about the PATRIOT Act,” Oren Teicher, the chief operating officer of the American Booksellers Association, said.

Pat Schroeder, President and CEO of the Association of American Publishers, said: "The Senate bill contains some very important safeguards for protecting library, bookstore and publisher records under Section 215-safeguards that we have been working to achieve for more than two years. We will continue to urge the Senate conferees to stand firm when the bill goes to House-Senate conference after Labor Day."

"The Senate has done what the full membership of the House was not allowed to do -- make sensible and critical improvements to search provisions of the PATRIOT Act, especially those that pertain to bookstore and library records," noted Larry Siems, Director of Freedom to Write and International Programs for PEN American Center. "These improvements come at no expense to national security, they are both sound and popular, and there is no reason they should not be part of the final legislation."